The City and Its Uncertain Walls

Starred review from November 18, 2024
Bestseller Murakami (Killing Commendatore) unspools an intoxicating fantasy of a parallel world. The unnamed middle-aged narrator recounts how, at 17, he fell in love with a 16-year-old girl who told him of a walled city in which her “real” self lives. At her invitation he wills himself into this world and takes a job as a Dream Reader at a library where the shelves are stocked with dreams, which he describes as “echoes of the minds left behind by real people.” The narrator then loses contact with the girl and the alternate world and embarks on an ordinary life, first as a businessman in Tokyo, then as head of a small library in an unnamed mountainous town. The ingenuity of Murakami’s tale lies in the resonances he establishes between the two worlds through depictions of an assistant librarian who calls to mind the narrator’s youthful girlfriend, a mentor who might be an elderly reflection of the narrator himself, and a 16-year-old boy who forms an obsessive interest in the narrator’s descriptions of the walled city. Even as Murakami forges a bridge between the parallel universes, he artfully preserves the ambiguity at the heart of a question posed by the narrator: “Is this world inside the high brick wall? Or outside it?” It’s an astonishing achievement. Agent: Amanda Urban, ICM Partners.